Sign in or create a free account to curate your search content.
At 9:28 p.m. on March 17, 1925, a methane gas explosion at Bethlehem Mine No. 41 in Barrackville, approximately three miles west of Fairmont in Marion County, killed 33 men instantly (see sidebar for complete list of victims). The men averaged 33 years of age.
Methane gas was a known hazard in coal mines, where adequate ventilation was essential to prevent dangerous accumulations. Even with ventilation, however, a spark from an electrical current or another ignition source could trigger a deadly explosion. Although various forms of mechanization had spread throughout the coal industry by the 1920s, miners at Barrackville still loaded coal by hand and relied on horses to haul it to the surface. Electrified trolleys transported miners into and from the workings. The explosion also killed 36 horses, underscoring the scale of destruction.
Investigators struggled to determine what triggered the explosion. The coroner’s jury could not establish an official cause, noting that much of the testimony was conflicting. A report from the state Department of Mines described the mine as one that “liberates explosive gas freely and has a tendency to dry out rapidly, making the dust problem very hard to overcome.” State Chief Mine Inspector R. M. Lambie likewise acknowledged the difficulty of reconstructing the disaster, describing the explosion as “very confusing and hard to trace.”
Suspicion of deliberate sabotage further complicated the investigation. An earlier explosion at the same mine in 1916 had been caused by a planted bomb. Following the 1925 disaster, three men were jailed in Marion County on suspicion of setting off a dynamite-glycerin bomb, but all were soon released for lack of evidence.
The coroner’s jury ultimately favored an accidental explosion, concluding that a slate fall had likely driven a steel beam into an electrical wire, creating a spark that ignited an accumulation of methane. The explosion had originated far from the mine shaft, a circumstance that investigators considered inconsistent with the theory that a bomb had caused the destruction.
Bethlehem Mine No. 41 was owned by the Bethlehem Coal Corporation and experienced other disasters in 1919 and 1935. Despite its deadly history, the mine continued operating under different ownership until 1982.
Efforts are currently underway to establish a memorial at Barrackville to honor the 33 men who lost their lives in the 1925 explosion.
Sources
“Coroner’s Report: Bethlehem Mine No. 41 at Barrackville.” West Virginia State Archives, Charleston. AR 1526 Department of Mines Fire and Disaster Reports, Box 1.
Dillon, Lacy. They Died in the Darkness. Parsons: McClain, 1976.
Lowdermilk, Sean. “’100 years is long enough’: Barrackville to Erect Mine Disaster Monument.” WBOY, June 24, 2025.
“Barrackville Mine Disaster.” Find a Grave. Web.
Marion County Death Records.
Cite This Article
"Barrackville Mine Disaster." e-WV: The West Virginia Encyclopedia. 18 November 2026. Web. Accessed: 18 November 2026.
This Exhibit has 25 Sections
This Exhibit has 22 Sections
18 Nov 2026