e-WV: The West Virginia Encyclopedia Online

Sign in or create a free account to curate your search content.

At 7:45 a.m. on February 6, 1915, an explosion at the Carlisle Mine near Oak Hill in Fayette County killed 23 men (see sidebar for complete list of victims). The blast was caused by a buildup of methane gas, likely ignited by a miner’s open-flame lamp. Based on the available evidence, two men died from the direct force of the explosion, while 20 others succumbed to asphyxiation. The remaining victim, Remus Chandler, an African American miner, suffered a skull fracture and died four days later at McKendree Hospital. Approximately 150 miners survived, although some sources place the number as high as 200.

The disaster claimed the lives of a particularly young workforce: Six of the 23 victims were 18 or younger, and the average age was 26.

The coroner’s jury absolved the company of responsibility and instead blamed fire bosses Romello and Raleigh Capri, who had inspected the mine that morning. The state Department of Mines’ official report noted that the mine was known to contain a “slight quantity of explosive gas, but not considered dangerous and open [flame] lights were used exclusively by miners and laborers.” However, investigators found that shortly before the miners entered the mine, the fire bosses had detected a small accumulation of gas in Room 11. According to the report, they had “failed to advise any person of the fact and marked the mine O.K. on a bulletin board kept for this purpose.” Under state law at the time, miners could not work in mines where gas conditions had been deemed dangerous. Despite the warning signs, the mine had been declared safe for work that morning.

The Carlisle Mine was owned by the White Oak Fuel Company, and its complex had been built in 1902 along the White Oak branch of the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway. The year after the disaster, the company replaced the mine’s wooden tipple with a steel structure.

The mine suffered another explosion in February 1951 before closing permanently in 1965.

Sources

West Virginia Department of Mines. Annual Report of the Department of Mine for the Fiscal Year Ending June 30, 1915. West Virginia Department of Mines, Charleston.

Dillon, Lacy. They Died in the Darkness. Parsons: McClain, 1976.

Fayette County Death Records.

Cite This Article

"Carlisle Mine Disaster." e-WV: The West Virginia Encyclopedia. 19 November 2026. Web. Accessed: 19 November 2026.

19 Nov 2026